TMNT 1988-1996 Updated Action Figure Prices (2016) Private/Public sales market trends

1993 Chef Boyardee TMNT All black with silver armor SUPER SHREDDER Exclusive Mailaway Figure. You needed 20 UPC barcodes to get one of these ultra rare figures. Few are still around to this day. Custom made acrylic case with included can of Chef Boyardee noodles.

1993 Chef Boyardee TMNT All black with silver armor SUPER SHREDDER Exclusive Mailaway Figure. You needed 20 UPC barcodes to get one of these ultra rare figures. Few are still around to this day. Custom made acrylic case with included can of Chef Boyardee noodles.

TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLE CRAZE
Cowabunga Dudes!  I am here today to inform you of the latest groovy current market trends of action figure sales of private and public auction purchases regarding Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle Toys.  This is concerning action figures released from 1988 to 1996 by Playmates and Bandai.  The more rare toys will be from the 1995-1996 waves, since they made fewer of them and stores were ordering less shipments for their toy department inventory.

Most of these prices I have concluded on my own.  This is based on recent market trends on eBay, private sales, craigslist, and conventions from the past 2 years.  The reason I am compiling this list is because most toy guides or price lists are horribly inaccurate when going against the ACTUAL sale prices of these figures.  Keep in mind, “asking price is different from selling price”.   The last good updated prices the Internet saw was back in 2006.  It’s been a while, dudes!  The links I have included mostly will say “0 results…”  Keep this in mind when searching for rare toys.  Search “Completed listings” or “Sold” listings to see what you just missed and how much it went for.  So, Here we go:

1993 TMNT Scratch the Cat, one of the most valuable TMNT toys ever produced. (Which isn't even that rare.)

1993 TMNT Scratch the Cat, one of the final figures to roll off the production line. Few stores ordered the last waves of TMNT toys. This one is punched with light wear on card. It is one of my white whales. One of the most valuable TMNT toys ever produced. (Which isn’t even that rare.)

MOST VALUABLE FIGURES
Some figures are considered valuable but not rare.  These toys go for way over what they are worth when you compare production line numbers and shelf orders from stores…. You can thank shows like Jordan’s “The Toyhunter” on Travel Channel for Scratch the cat prices.   People seem to forget about his canine friend, Hot Spot.  This includes the following:

Scratch $1200
Hot Spot $550
Shogun Shoate Purple Weapons $375
Shogun Shoate Blue Weapons $250
Shogun Triceraton Purple Weapons $700
Shogun Triceraton Blue Weapons $500
Any of the Japanese Figures $100
Movie Star Splinter No Fur W/Tooth $150
Any Undercover Turtle feat. Cloth Trenchcoat $600

The coveted most valuable and holy grail piece of all TMNT toy collectors: 1994 Mint on Card, completely untouched TMNT Shogun Triceraton, the holy mother of all TMNT Toys. With purple weapons, of course. (The rarest).

The coveted most valuable and holy grail piece of all TMNT toy collectors: 1994 Mint on Card, completely untouched TMNT Shogun Triceraton, the holy mother of all TMNT Toys. With purple weapons, of course. (The rarest).

MOST POPULAR COLLECTOR FIGURES
The list below contains the collector list most are seeking.  These are your main figures everyone is trying to grab.  Some are common, but some are more uncommon due to weapons, colors, and variations released by Playmates and Mirage Studios.  The Japan figures were made in conjunction with Bandai.  Teenage Mutant HERO Turtles were released overseas in the UK and other parts of Europe.  While not rare, they are just a cool factor to us folks here in the United States.

SUPER RARE! 1994 Shogun Mike (in Gold Armor), Mint on card.

SUPER RARE! 1994 Shogun Mike (in Gold Armor), Mint on card, light shelf wear, sticker wear on bubble, one crease on upper left corner. These toys came in Silver armor. 1 per case

Here’s the main list of popular TMNT action figures for the collector:
Warrior Rocksteady $200
Warrior Chrome Dome $200
Warrior Winged Turtles $100
Sumo Turtles $84 with gold coin $100
The Turtleflauge series $100
The Deluxe Turtleflauge series $125
Mutant Masters $50
Dino Turtles $75-$100
Coil Force Turtles $35
Muta-Force Turtles $100
Mini-mutants Playsets $50
Ace Duck with hat OFF, with pop up display $200
Ace Duck with hat off $100
Ace Duck with hat ON $85
1997 Dino Turtles $300
Mini mutant mutant combo/pizza police /firefightin combo $75
Giant troll series $200
Sumo turtles $100
Slash-Purple Belt, Yellow “S” $50
Leonardo/Raphael/Donatello/Michaelangelo w/ Fan Club forms soft heads $185 each
Slash-Purple Belt, Red “S”, Mustard Yellow Chest $75
Genghis Frog-Gold Belt $350
Genghis Frog-Black Belt $50
April O’Neil no stripes $200
April Orange & Blue, no “Press” $75
General Traag with Collector Card  $100
Movie Star Turtles w/ collector cards  $85
Movie Star Turtles w/ collector gold coins $100
Raph as the Mummy blue weapons $50
Raph as the Mummy purple weapons $40
Raph as the Mummy orange weapons $30
Raph as the Mummy red weapons $20
Slam Dunkin’ Don White Shirt Wal-Mart excl w/ collector card $100
HotHead w/ collector card $150
HotHead blue weapons $50
Shogun Don w/ second version collector card $45
The 4 re-release Storage shell TMNT w/ collector cards $100 each
Krang’s Android Body w/ collector card and coin $250
Rocksteady 1988 w/ soft head w/ 10-back card and pop-up display $250
Shredder 1988 w/ soft head w/ 10-back card and pop-up display $150
Baxter Stockman 1988 pop-up display $150
Figures With Fan Club Forms (Soft Heads) $150
Figures With Pop Up Displays $150
April O’ Neil No “Press” yellow/orange $55
Genghis Frog W/Tan Belt Off $200
Giant Slam Dunkin’ Don $50
Airforce Mutation Donatello $30
Airforce Mutation Raphael $30
Shogun Mike Gold Armor $400
Black Super Shredder Excl Chef Boyardee (20 UPC) Mailaway Variant $350
… and matching TMNT Chef Boyardee Tin Can (IF you can find one!) $25
Channel 6 Newsvan $600
Leo, The Sewer Surfer W/Mondo Mutant Surfer Tube $150
Scuba Divin’ Raph W/Psych-Out Spin-Out Scuba Tube $200
Giant Trolls $150 each
Giant Mutatin $100
Sewer Playset $500
Technodrome sealed $1300
Technodrome opened w/box $400
Technodrome scout $150
Turtle Blimp $300
Turtle Blimp II $200

Extremely rare holy grail piece from Mirage Studios - Peter Laird's own TMNT UNDERCOVER LEONARDO 1994 MOC Ninja Turtles with CLOTH COAT & COIN, signed by Peter Laird.

Extremely rare holy grail piece directly from Mirage Studios – Peter Laird’s own TMNT UNDERCOVER LEONARDO 1994 Mint on Card Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Undercover Leo with CLOTH COAT & COIN, signed by Peter Laird.

 

 

Extremely rare holy grail piece from Mirage Studios - Peter Laird's own TMNT UNDERCOVER LEONARDO 1994 MOC Ninja Turtles with CLOTH COAT & COIN, signed by Peter Laird.

Extremely rare holy grail piece from Mirage Studios – Peter Laird’s own TMNT UNDERCOVER LEONARDO 1994 MOC Ninja Turtles with CLOTH COAT & COIN, signed by Peter Laird.

SUPER ULTRA RARE FIGURES
Finally, the list you all been waiting for:  The Top 15 “Super Ultra Mega Turbo Rare” List of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.  You will very rarely find these on auction sites or at a garage or estate sale.  There’s not many left around anymore out in the market.  Most likely the remaining ones are in Peter Laird’s basement or someone’s deceased loved ones’ attic crawlspace.  You should try and hunt these down like it were the cure for Cancer:

  1. Undercover Leo with cloth trenchcoat and gold coin $800
  2. Don’s Camo Hydro Skimmer $1800
  3. Leo’s Camo Blitz Cycle $1300
  4. Genghis Frog w/ Bagged Weapons $800
  5. Slash-Purple Belt, Red “S”, Bright Yellow Chest $250
  6. Cyber Jet $700
  7. Cyber Rover $600
  8. Warrior Rocksteady $200
  9. Ralph as the Mummy w/ unpainted chest w/unpainted knees (VERY RARE) $100
  10. Sumo Mike w/ gold coin $150
  11. Pizzaface w/green knife w/red on hat w/hero card $150
  12. Undercover Mike with cloth trenchcoat and collectible card $700
  13. Ray Fillet w/ Purple “V” on 3 Hero Card $150
  14. Tattoo with tattoo on belly $125
  15. Shogun Don (Gold) Ultra Rare but DO EXIST $1000
Another Holy Grail Piece. 1988 Wave 1, Rubber soft head Original April O'Neil with no Press Pass, No stripes, Mint on card. Extremely rare to find an unpainted one with no press pass at all, let alone mint on card.

Another Holy Grail Piece. 1988 Wave 1, Rubber soft head Original April O’Neil with no Press Pass, No stripes, Mint on card. Extremely rare to find an unpainted one with no press pass at all, let alone mint on card.

I hope you enjoy this list.  You may or may not agree to it, but this is from my research and my collection.  Please leave a comment if you’d like to weigh in.

And Finally, if you’d like to see MY Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle Collection, here you go…

KaptainMyke’s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle Collection of Toys, Comic Books, Art, and Posters on Pinterest. 

1994 TMNT Shogun Shoate, mint on card, purple weapons. Extremely rare! One of the top 5 rarest and most valuable figures in the toy line.

1994 TMNT Shogun Shoate, mint on card, purple weapons. Extremely rare! One of the top 5 rarest and most valuable figures in the toy line.


2 thoughts on “TMNT 1988-1996 Updated Action Figure Prices (2016) Private/Public sales market trends

  1. Does anyone know the value of an original ninja turtle bowling set where the figurines are the pins such as villains and turtles? It’s yellow. Don’t remember too much about it. I just know it’s still at my parents

    • I believe it’s called “TMNT Poppin Pins Bowling” with a pizza disc. A sealed one can go for $150 and a loose but complete one can go for $40-$50. Great find!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Spam Protection *